Play Video
Firm Logo

Settlement vs. Trial: What's the Best Option for Your New Jersey Dog Bite Case?

Settlement vs. Trial What's the Best Option for Your New Jersey Dog Bite CaseSettlement vs. Trial What's the Best Option for Your New Jersey Dog Bite Case

When you've experienced a dog bite in New Jersey, a rush of emotions may flood over you—pain, anxiety, and confusion among them. A key question that often arises once you've decided to pursue legal action is, "Should I go for a settlement or take my case to trial?" At the Law Offices of Harold J. Gerr, we understand the complexities that come with making this significant choice. This article aims to shed light on the pros and cons of both options, empowering you to make an informed decision tailored to your unique circumstances.

Understanding Dog Bite Laws in New Jersey

Before diving into the intricacies of settlements and trials, it's important to establish a basic understanding of New Jersey's dog bite laws. According to New Jersey Statute 4:19-16, the owner of the dog is strictly liable for damages caused by their dog's bite, regardless of whether the dog has shown aggressive behavior in the past. This sets the stage for the victim to consider their legal options—settlement or trial.

What is a Settlement?

A settlement is an agreement reached between the injured party and the dog owner or their insurance company. The purpose of a settlement is to resolve the matter quickly, often with a lump-sum payment, thereby avoiding the uncertainties of a court trial.

What is a Trial?

In contrast, a trial is a formal legal process where the matter is taken before a judge or jury. The trial involves presenting evidence, testimonies, and legal arguments, following which the judge or jury renders a verdict. If you win, you may be awarded damages for medical expenses, pain and suffering, lost wages, and other losses.

Pros and Cons of a Settlement


  • Speed: Settlements are generally quicker than trials, getting you the compensation you need faster.
  • Certainty: You know exactly how much you'll receive, avoiding the unpredictability of a trial.
  • Privacy: Settlements are private, protecting you from public scrutiny.


  • Potential for Lower Compensation: You may receive less than what a court may award you.
  • Lack of Accountability: The dog owner does not formally admit guilt.

Pros and Cons of a Trial


  • Potential for Higher Compensation: Courts may award a larger sum if they find the dog owner at fault.
  • Accountability: A guilty verdict holds the dog owner accountable for their actions.


  • Time-Consuming: Trials can take several months, even years, to conclude.
  • Public Scrutiny: Trials are public records, which might not be ideal for all victims.
  • Unpredictability: The outcome and the compensation are uncertain until the verdict is passed.

Settlement vs. Trial: Factors to Consider

When choosing between a settlement and a trial, several factors should be evaluated:

  • Strength of Your Case: If you have compelling evidence, a trial might be more favorable.
  • Financial Needs: If you need money immediately for medical expenses, a settlement could be faster.
  • Emotional Toll: Trials can be emotionally draining; consider your mental health.
  • Legal Costs: Attorney fees can add up if a case goes to trial.

Statute of Limitations in New Jersey Dog Bite Cases

It's crucial to be aware of the statute of limitations when considering legal action for a dog bite case in New Jersey. According to New Jersey law, you have two years from the date of the bite to file a lawsuit. Missing this deadline could result in the forfeiture of your right to seek compensation. Therefore, it's vital to consult with your legal team as soon as possible to preserve your legal rights.

What evidence do I need for my case?

Gathering evidence like medical records, photographs of personal injuries, and eyewitness accounts can strengthen your case, whether you're considering a settlement or a trial.

How long does a settlement usually take?

The duration can vary, but settlements are generally quicker, often taking a few weeks to several months.

Can I switch from a settlement to a trial?

Yes, if both parties cannot agree on a settlement, you can decide to take your case to trial.

Are there any upfront costs for pursuing a dog bite case?

This depends on your arrangement with your legal team. Many law firms, including ours, operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay only if you win the case.

Contact Law Offices of Harold J. Gerr Today for a Free Consultation About Your Dog Bite Case

Navigating the legal landscape after a dog bite can be overwhelming. At the Law Offices of Harold J. Gerr, we're not just attorneys; we're your dedicated partners in this legal journey. Our commitment to clarity, compassion, and personalized legal guidance ensures that you're never in the dark about your options—be it settlement or trial.

Located in Highland Park, New Jersey, we have years of experience dealing specifically with dog bite cases in the Garden State. From collecting crucial evidence to advocating fiercely on your behalf, we strive to secure the best possible outcome for you.

Don't let legal complexities add to your stress. Let us help you take control of your situation and seek the compensation you deserve. Contact us today for a no-obligation, confidential consultation.

$500 K

Car Accident With Government Vehicle

$845 K

Commercial Truck Accident

$500 K

School Bus Accident

$1 M

Pedestrian Accident


top 100 Awardtop 100 Award
Crime Victim Bar AwardCrime Victim Bar Award
American Association for Justice AwardAmerican Association for Justice Award
Middlesex County Bar AwardMiddlesex County Bar Award
NJ Bar AwardNJ Bar Award
distinguished awarddistinguished award
Brain Injury AwardBrain Injury Award
BBB AwardBBB Award
Play Video
"Mr. Gerr helped me a great deal following a head injury I incurred. He was knowledgeable, competent, kind and reassuring. I highly recommend him."
  • Location Icon

    The Law Offices Of Harold J, Gerr

    47 Raritan Ave., 2nd Floor,Highland Park, NJ 08904

    732-537-8570 | 732-249-4600

    Fax: 732-249-0643

    Map + Directions
© 2024 The Law Offices of Harold J. Gerr. All Rights Reserved.Disclaimer.Site Map.